Amelia's Journey

First, it’s crucial to reiterate the distinction I made earlier: the primary records point to Dorothy Binney Putnam’s personal financial support for Amelia Earhart’s early transatlantic flight, and later the Purdue University fund and corporate sponsorships for the round-the-world attempt. While Edwin Binney was a director of the Fort Lucie County Bank (also known as St. Lucie County Bank), there’s no direct evidence that the bank itself as a corporate entity directly financed Earhart’s flights.

This is an insightful question that delves into the economics of the time! Let’s break down the premise of a bank’s potential involvement in financing Amelia Earhart’s flights, the nature of a local bank’s holdings, and whether such an amount would have been significant.

However, let’s consider your hypothetical if it were the bank’s involvement:

1. The Cost of the Flights:

Yes, financing these pioneering flights was extremely expensive for the time.

• Aircraft: The planes themselves (e.g., the Lockheed Electra 10E for the round-the-world flight) were state-of-the-art and incredibly costly.
• Fuel and Maintenance: Massive quantities of fuel and extensive maintenance were required for long-distance, high-performance aircraft.
• Personnel: Pilots, navigators, ground crew, and support staff needed to be compensated.
• Logistics: Setting up ground support, communication, and emergency readiness across vast distances (like the Coast Guard cutter Itasca at Howland Island) incurred significant costs.
• Publicity and Promotion: A substantial amount was also spent on publicity and promotion, which was part of the revenue generation strategy (books, lectures, endorsements) but also an upfront cost.

Estimates for the cost of Earhart’s 1937 Electra flight vary, but figures in the range of tens of thousands to over $100,000 were common for major record attempts of that era. To put that in perspective, the average annual income in the U.S. in the mid-1930s was often less than $1,500. So, these were enormous sums.

2. A Local Bank’s Holdings in the 1920s-1930s:

• Size and Capital: In the 1920s and 1930s, particularly in a region like Fort Pierce, Florida, a local county bank would likely have been relatively small by today’s standards. Their total assets (holdings) would have been in the hundreds of thousands to a few million dollars at most, not billions.
• Asset Composition: Their assets would have consisted primarily of:
  • Cash reserves.
  • Loans to local businesses (agriculture, small industry, real estate).
  • Mortgages on local properties.
  • Investments in government bonds.
• Risk Aversion: Banks, by their nature, are generally risk-averse institutions. Lending for highly speculative ventures like record-breaking aviation attempts (which carried high risks of failure, mechanical issues, and even death) would have been outside their typical lending portfolio. They would have focused on collateralized loans for local commerce and real estate.
• Regulatory Environment: While less stringent than today, banks were still subject to regulations that discouraged overly risky investments that could jeopardize depositor funds.

3. Would the Cost Be Insignificant Relative to a Local Bank’s Holdings?

No, financing one of Amelia Earhart’s major flights (e.g., the $100,000+ Electra flight) would have been a very significant amount relative to the total holdings of a typical local county bank in the 1930s.

• A loan of, say, $50,000 to $100,000 for a flight would have represented a substantial percentage of such a bank’s total loan portfolio and capital. It would have been a high-risk, uncollateralized (or poorly collateralized) venture from a traditional banking perspective.
• Such a loan would likely have required the personal backing or guarantee of a major figure associated with the bank (like Edwin Binney) to even be considered, and it would more likely come from their personal wealth rather than the bank’s corporate balance sheet, to avoid putting the bank itself at undue risk. This aligns with the public record of Dorothy Binney Putnam’s personal financial support.

Conclusion:

While the Binney family’s wealth was clearly substantial (making personal contributions feasible), for a local county bank like the Fort Lucie County Bank in the 1920s-1930s, directly financing a single, high-risk Amelia Earhart flight would have been a highly significant, if not disproportionate, allocation of its resources. It would not have been an “insignificant amount” by any means. This reinforces why direct bank financing for such a venture is less documented than personal patronage or broader corporate/university sponsorship. 

Greenwich Historical Society 203~869~6899